Apr 25, 2014
Spironolactone Failed as Aldo-Antagonist but Reduces Heart Failure Hospitalizations
Despite the fact that the study was negative, they observed that patients who took the aldosterone inhibitor spironolactone had significantly fewer heart-failure hospitalizations.
Pfeffer and other experts agreed that TOPCAT points to spironolactone as an option for patients with HFPEF as long as safety issues, like worsening renal function or hyperkalemia, are addressed. He said he will now use the drug on his HFPEF patients, although it will be up to physicians to decide for themselves. "We have a generic medication that we can show how to use safely and, we do believe, relieves the burden these patients have."
TOPCAT randomized 3445 heart-failure patients aged at least 50 with an LVEF >45% at 270 sites in six countries to receive the aldosterone antagonist or placebo. At the end of the study, 206 out of 1722 patients on spironolactone (12 percent) had been hospitalized for heart failure, compared to 245 of 1723 patients (14 percent) given placebo. There were no significant differences in adverse events, except, Pfeffer emphasized, more hyperkalemia with spironolactone and more hypokalemia on placebo; there were no hyperkalemia-related deaths.
Dr Clyde Yancy (Northwestern University, Chicago, IL) said, "The first thing about TOPCAT is to acknowledge the study results: they are negative. The second thing is to interpret the results very carefully and realize that there's not a signal, there's actually a message: for the first time we can modify the natural history of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction. And the third is that with the unique prism that I have, as a lifelong practitioner in this space, as someone who writes guidelines and does clinical trials, my deduction, looking at the data from all those difference lenses, is that I will use it as a clinician." Akshay S. Desai, MD, MPH, advanced heart failure specialist, BWH Division of Cardiovascular Medicine thinks that “The results of TOPCAT will help inform clinicians as they make treatment decisions for this understudied population.”
Once again here we have an example of how a negative result can lead us to new discoveries.
Written by Dr. Belén Suárez for The All Results Journals.